This site is made possible with support from you. Don't let that go to your head.

With The White Stripes coming to DC this November, it’s time to take a closer look at their last release, Elephant. New Life in the District contributor Jay Newell cuts through the hype and gets to the heart of this massive album.

The White Stripes, Elephant

by Jay
Permalink  |  This article is out of date

The overwhelming response to the White Stripes’ breakthrough White Blood Cells, made their major-label follow up one of the most anxiously awaited releases of the year. Elephant finds Jack & Meg White (divorcées, not siblings) adjusting to their newfound fame and success, pushed to meet the expectations and hype placed on them by artistically expanding while invariably actively working to quell any fears of “selling out�?.

Appropriately the White Stripes take more risks than on any previous outing, occasionally venturing away from their minimalist punk/garage-rock to introduce ballads, as well as more overt elements of blues, folk, pop and even show-tunes. The resulting Elephant, like its namesake, is a beast of many extremes. With visceral anthems like “The Hardest Button to Button�? and the infectious “Seven Nation Army,�? Elephant crashes through as a powerful juggernaut, knocking everything from its path. Yet on the acoustic “You’ve Got Her in Your Pocket�? there emerges a more docile but clumsy creature, far different than the dark and unwieldy mammoth that lumbers in on “Little Acorns.�?

Elephant also marks the first additions to their bare bones instrumentation. Judicious incorporation of basses and keyboards further expand the range, thankfully fleshing out their razor-thin sonic range without overpowering the band’s forceful simplicity. Although the resulting dynamics allow for a few more accessible songs, no one should worry about a lack of midrange punch and gutbucket abuse still prominent throughout (skeptics should be directed to “Black Math�?).

Meg’s vocal offering, “In the Cold, Cold Night�? is actually a refreshing break. A slinky affair chock full of sexy schoolgirl innocence à la Peggy Lee. The song is the first of a trio of songs concerning teenage sexuality, “You make me feel a little older / like a full grown woman might / but when you’re gone I grow colder / come to me again in the cold, cold night.�?“There’s no Room for You Here�? sounds like the bastard lovechild of Queen and the Jon Spencer Blues Explosion (with a pinch of Don Vliet thrown in for good measure) as one symphonic tsunami of satanic Freddie Mercurys ebbs to expose a deceptively innocent verse in its trough before another wave of overdubbed vocals crashes. Despite regurgitating the “Dead Leaves�? melody, this is one of the album’s true dynamic highlights.The album’s peak doesn’t come until the end, but “The Air Neath my Fingers,�? may be the White Stripes’ most fully realized song to date.

At its best, Elephant is visceral, infectious, exciting, and clever. At its worst, Elephant manages to be both repetitive and uneven; despite drawing from broader palettes, they tediously stretch the same ideas over most of the album.

There are some moments of true genius, but they’re unfortunately obscured by lots of filler. Jack White is capable of explosive guitar as well as great songwriting, and Meg provides an extremely effective base (with AC/DC now in geriatrics, she may be the reigning champion of absolutely-no-frills drumming).

They’ve proved that there’s a lot more in their playbook than Jon Spencer Blues Explosion rehash and recycled MC5 licks, with a little more quality control, the White Stripes may prove to be everything that they’ve been hyped to be.

Comments are closed.

Life in the District is a guide to getting by in Washington, DC.

Powered by WordPress

Disclaimer: We are not a professional news organization. At best, we're amateur rabble-rousers, at worst, we're just a bunch of people who love the sounds of our own voices as much as we love this city. If we could afford a lawyer, he'd tell us to tell you that any commentary, advice, or other content on this site is meant for your (or our) entertainment only.

Creative Commons License
The content on the site belongs to its authors. But, we play nice with others so this work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial- ShareAlike 2.5 License.

Some feeds are available: entries and comments.